Why do you Read what you Read?

image thumb7 Why do you Read what you Read?Dilbert: Lately, the only thing keeping me from becoming a serial killer is my distaste for manual labor.

Dogbert: Preaching to the choir.

Anytime a person prefaces a statement with “now don’t get me wrong but …” you can bet someone already has the match struck to set off the fireworks. And more often than not, the person making the statement is the one holding the match.

Since many who read my articles are writers I’m sure what I am about to say will come across like preaching to the choir. However, from my experience, a lot of people in the choir need to listen up. I mean, have you ever watched a church service on TV and noticed how many in full view of the world were fighting naps and fidgeting around like six year olds?

With that long-winded preface out of the way let’s get down to business.

NOW DON’T GET ME WRONG BUT … most informer types are a bit full of themselves. Before you think I’m just talking about writers, far from it. Informer types are everywhere and populate every vocation of life. These are the people who not only think carefully about a lot of things but for some reason feel compelled to share those thoughts with others.

Over the past four years I have immersed myself in the community or writers. During that time I have learned much and am deeply thankful to more seasoned writers that have taken me under their wing. I have also observed the informer types at work. They are the ones who are sure they know how everything should be done and are quick to tell you that your way is the wrong way. They draw lines in the sand and invite people to choose sides over issues like Christian vs. secular fiction, romance vs. suspense, and the list goes on. Most of these informer types are people deeply dedicated to their craft and have the best of intentions. At least I hope so because all too often I have been one of them.

So where am I going with all of this? I’m glad you asked.

Writers, especially the informer types, also write and converse a lot about how books should be written. For the sake of this conversation let’s pretend every writer in the world is listening in and has been gagged so they can’t interrupt with some piece of opinionated information. Should you be a writer, you can only answer the following questions if you take an oath to put that part of your brain on hold for a few seconds. So here goes …

Why do you read what you read? What makes a book good to you? If I asked you to critique the last novel you read (not as a writer but as a reader) what comments would you make about it?

My guess is most readers will answer these questions without a mention of point of view, choice of tenses, hero’s journeys, or scene placement. Sure all of those things are important but when handled well become invisible with the story taking center stage.

We’ll see what other have to say but I have a suspicion their answers will be some version of, “I read what I read because it’s what I like to read.” For now, I’ll try to put that Informer part of my brain on hold and see how you the reader inform me.

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Asimov's "Mule" made enough of an impression on me that I can still picture him though it has been at least 20 years since I read the Foundation Trilogy.

I think I read for at least a few reasons. I read to escape. I read to be entertained. I read to incite emotion... you know root for the good guy, dislike the bad guy. The books I'm currently reading are The Well of Ascension by Brandon Sanderson and Foundation by Isaac Asimov.

I read for characters, in hopes those characters get what they deserve - whether they are virtuous or villanous or somewhere in between - and to experience their journey through their eyes. While I'm visiting with them, I want to be transported to a unique, rich setting that sparks the imagination. Books that I've read lately that accomplished that well - at least, IMHO - were S. Thomas Russell's A Battle Won and Cherie Priest's Dreadnought. Those books pull you right into their protagonists, whether it's the maligned commander of a 17th century ship-of-the-line or a Civil War nurse caught in a cross-country journey aboard a steampunk armored train.

I read what I read MAINLY because of the characters. I want to feel them, hear them, know them. Mind you, if they're headed into immediate danger that will involve life changing choices, a splash of humour and bigger-than-they-originally-thought consequences so much the better :) But to me, it's all about the people in the book. Give me an intriguing cast and I'm destined to read and re-read, even if only to hang out and reminisce.

I also read to escape, or to be transported to another time & place. I grew up reading Stephen King, & I think my favorite book of his is The Eyes of The Dragon. Although I really enjoyed The Stand. I have a warped sense of how I want a story to end, I suppose, and I do not like a whole book if I dislike the ending. ;) (For example I loved the way Hannibal ended because Clarice & Dr. Lecter ended up together).

This is the sort of question librarians are taught to ask when we do "Readers Advisory". So I'm going to answer this with my reader/librarian hat on. I read what I read for 3 reasons. #1 I like to read non-fiction for information, but I like the information to be engaging and I like personal anecdotes. #2 I read for stress relief. My go-to genre is mystery. And I enjoy series mysteries that center around a character or characters. (Martha Grimes's Richard Jury books, Lilian Jackson Braun's "Cat Who" series). Though they're not mysteries, Daniel Silva's Gabriel Allon books satisfy the same need. I like returning to their world again and again to see what they're up to. It's a form of escapism. #3 I like to read engaging children's books. I read to my kids every day and love when a picture book is fun to read aloud (alliteration, voice, cadence, humor, repetition). It's tough for me to nail down whether I prefer books that are more "plot-driven" or books that are more "character driven". Right now I'd have to say I love a strong character (with whom I usually don't identify) and I like to see how they overcome hurdles (the mystery) and reveal themselves (over the series)

(cont. because apparently it was too long) What makes a book good to me is taking the journey to get inside someone else's skin, to feel their sensations. I love the variety of styles, voices. I hate formulaic and rule-bound novels. The novel I just finished was a bust for me - which I didn't expect because of its immense popularity, being in the genre I like, and the sterling recommendations. But I can say succinctly why I didn't like it: there were only two peripheral characters I vaguely cared about and one of them appeared near the end of the story, and the other one got killed off. The other characters (the co-protagonists) were totally undesirable and I could've cared less about them. Give me good characters or forget it.

Tim, we've been down similar streets with this writing journey and I think we hold similar opinions on some of those avenues taken by writers. To answer the questions: "Why do you read what you read? What makes a book good to you? If I asked you to critique the last novel you read (not as a writer but as a reader) what comments would you make about it?" I read genres which intrique me. The inside of police/FBI, military, covert operative conduct is exciting, dangerous, and meaningful. In contemporary novels (i.e. women's fiction) give me characters who are three dimensional, intricate, and passionate. I would like to read some good romance, but in CBA it's fairly rare, and I'm not going there in ABA.

I assume we're talking about fiction here? Why do I read the fiction I read? It depends on the day. Sometimes I need something light and easy to follow, and then I often opt for YA books (for instance, authors Shannon Hale, Margaret Peterson Haddix). Other days I like it to be complex and have sub-plots and suspense. Either way, I read to slip into an alternate world. And it's nice when I learn new things along the way. It's good when it is unique in some way (Hale is amazing at this), when the characters are round, when the pace is fast, and when--even though the book's world may not be like ours and the characters are flawed or maybe even the good guys don't necessarily "win"--I still feel grounded because there is a sense of order, purpose, or of Light.

See above. :) Before that, "Under the Dome" by Stephen King -- I read it before my husband and had to wait for him to join me under the dome. It took him a month, and the Dome effect affected him for at least two more weeks. Many (most? all?) of King's novels have that effect. While we were reading the Dark Tower series, we spoke like Roland - saying "Thankee Sai",and using "Palaver" and "Ka" and "Wheel" in casual conversation for weeks on end. The Circle Trilogy (Black, Red, White) by Ted Dekker was the one before that. Brad read it, but wasn't transported like I was. so I was alone in the Black Forest, and the desert, and Red Pools with the Hoarde and the Ring and Jason and the viris and ... Ahhhh, I've GOT to read that again. Blessings Cat

I just read Hanne's comment, and was reminded that I wanted to say - I like to read to escape.. To me, a good book is one that entertains me. A GREAT book is one that transports me to another place or time or family or life so skillfully, I forget I'm reading a book. I no longer hear or see what's around me. It amazes my husband. :)

So what's the last book that transported you? A term is used of some writing that is called Magical Realism. For me, Athol Dickson and Dean Koontz fall into that category. Both, in very different ways, make me forget I am even reading a book.

Since I don't have an informer side to me (snicker) it was easy for me to consider the last novel I read from a reader's view. (snicker snicker). But seriously, I guess to answer your question, I'll answer your challenge to review the last novel I read - Biblical fiction about Michal, King David's first wife. I didn't think I'd like it at first because Michael and David seemed like caricatures of romance novel leads. I kinda got into it, tho, because the characters grew and changed, and I like to read about life in general during Bible times - the housing, clothing, food, culture, etc. I had just finished reading another novel about David, and in comparison the characters were shallow and weak and the plot-depth was lacking, but I liked it because it entertained me. How did I do? :-) Love Cat

What as the other novel you read about David?

"Day of War" by Cliff Graham. Wow. I wanted to cry because Book 2 isn't out yet. I have never ever wanted to join someone on a battlefield before, but I was so glad I was there to witness David....... okay, I don't want to give too much away. Galaxies of difference between the two novels.

I suspected Day of War was the other. I have an interview coming up with Cliff Graham so watch for it.

I read what I read for a variety of reason. I have books people send me to read and review. I read books friends recommend to me. I read books I've heard about perhaps from the author himself. To be honest, I read fewer and fewer books just because I want to. The thing is, I like a lot (a LOT) of the books I read for some other reason. But it's a special treat for me to go to the library and pick out a book I want to read just because I want to read it. Becky

This isn't fair!!! Waaaaaa!!!! I can't put the Informer part of my brain on hold! >_< Okay... I read to escape reality. I like suspense, murder mysteries, things that stretch my imagination (but not quite all the way into fantasy). I'm not much on sappy romance. I like strange twists, unexpected turns, and endings that I don't really see coming. I want the world the author creates to be realistic, no matter what century or what planet it takes place on. :) I like characters who have flaws because none of us is perfect. And I just like to read what I read because it's what I like to read... :D

I totally agree, I like the same kinds of books. But add Historical Fiction, as long as it's an author who actually researches, and doesn't just write whatever comes into their head. And if they include real people in the fiction, don't make them do something that never could have happened, unless you are labeling it as "Alternate" Historical Fiction.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] I asked “Why do you Read What You Read?” here is what some of you [...]

%d bloggers like this: